High Court finds police raid on Nicky Hager was illegal

Wellington High Court judge Justice Clifford issued his judgement today on the legality of the police search of Nicky Hager’s home on 2 October 2014. The judge found that the search was illegal.

He said that the Police had failed to disclose relevant information to the Judge who issued the warrant. As a result, he formally declared that the warrant was “fundamentally unlawful”.

He also found that the search was therefore unlawful. Justice Clifford also expressed concerns about other aspects of the Police’s actions. Mr Hager said he is very happy about the decision, for his family and because of the important principles it upholds.

“The heart of the case is the public’s right to receive information about the actions of people in positions of authority.

This decision acknowledges that confidential sources used in investigative journalism, in this case my book Dirty Politics, deserve legal protection.”

More hearings will follow on other police actions taken against Mr Hager and on the subject of costs and damages.

But Mr Hager said this decision was the most important one, affecting all news media and also present and future whistle blowers.

“This decision is very good news for New Zealand journalism,” he said.

Mr Hager thanked the large numbers of people who donated money to help cover court costs and the experts who wrote affidavits supporting his case.


Mr Hager and his lawyers will be available to answer questions outside the Wellington High Court in Molesworth Street at 4:45 pm today. Me Hager’s lawyer, Felix Geiringer, will also be available for comment or more information on 022 0243402 after 5:15 pm.


Chapter 4: The Crusher and the Attack Dog

Judith Collins has been returned to Cabinet. Below is an extract from Chapter 4 of Dirty Politics, to remind the public of her behaviour when she was last in office.

Collins was shown to have leaked a stream of information to Whale Oil blogger Cameron Slater. The most notable example was her leaking the private details of a public servant, who faced death threats and public humiliation after this information was published by Slater.

Collins has yet to be cleared of any of the misdeeds revealed in the book.

Dirty Politics: Chapter 4 extract

Latest news: December 2015

The Impunity Files, Police Edition: Trolling for Rawshark – Kiwipolitico

The watchdog and the rottweilers – Radio NZ

Xero boss withdraws advertising from Whaleoil – NZ Herald

Political roundup: The struggle for integrity – NZ Herald

‘Digital first’ strategies put journalists last – Scoop

Spinning the return of Judith Collins – Nicky Hager on Pundit

A Poor Millennial’s Guide to Bluffing Your Way to a Bearable Christmas – Newsworthy

Surprise Cabinet reshuffle will see Judith Collins return to Corrections – Stuff.co.nz

Safety, trust and transparency – Otago Daily Times

Judith Collins says she never thought about giving up because she wasn’t guilty – Stuff.co.nz

Toby Manhire: Top dog in annus hangoveris is … – NZ Herald

Judith Collins returns to Cabinet: biography and timeline – Stuff.co.nz

2015 Roger Award Finalists Named – Scoop

Latest news: November 2015

$10k To Look Deep Inside The Police Hunt For Rawshark – Scoop

Hager, Whale Oil, Dirty Politics, Rawshark, and what the police should have done – NZ Herald

The Whaledump Saga: Scooby-Doo Edition – Keith Ng on Public Address

Labour’s Phil Twyford ‘won’t be silenced’ by planned Simon Lusk attack – Stuff.co.nz

Police go to John Key over hacker’s identity – NZ Herald

Handling of Slater gripe stunned cop – NZ Herald

Phil Twyford won’t be intimidated by smear campaign – NZ Herald

Editorial: We need to care about protecting our rights – Wanganui Chronicle

So what’s this Taxpayers’ Union, which purports to represent us all? – NZ Herald

Intelligence Community must ‘Finish what we have started’ – Scoop

Getting it out in the open: reviewing the OIA – Radio NZ

“A Kick Back Against Government Intolerance” – an Interview with Nicky Hager – The Spinoff